Survivor Season Rankings
I truly believe Survivor offers more than any other show in television history. No matter what kind of media consumer you are, there is likely a season of Survivor that appeals to your interests.
Fan of game shows and complex strategy? There's a season for that.
Intense drama and developing narratives? Yep.
What about trashy reality TV or adult comedies? Absolutely.
And what elevates Survivor above the aforementioned genres/interests is its focus on real people in a real-life situation. Being marooned on an island obviously reveals one's true instincts and personalities, but being put on a TV show complicates that idea and blurs the distinction between fact and fiction, human and character, authenticity and performance. Whereas scripted television permits viewers to observe characters from afar, a show like Survivor forces us into constant conversation with these characters. Any opinion we may have is positioning us in relation to these characters, because they very well could be us. And so this unique viewing experience is one I recommend to everyone. Hopefully, these season rankings further underscore that recommendation.
Light spoilers to follow.
Enjoy.
40. Survivor: Redemption Island (22)
Even the worst season of Survivor is compelling TV. But Redemption Island certainly tests the patience of even the most loyal Survivor viewers. This season sees the return of two of the most notorious players in Survivor history: Russell Hantz and "Boston" Rob Mariano. The contrast between how these two players are received by their respective tribes makes for an interesting premerge, but really saps the season of any drama beyond that point. The season also introduces a pretty terrible twist in the form of Redemption Island, affording voted-out players the opportunity to compete to back into the game. It's not the worst twist the show has ever seen (I'll get to that later) but it does diminish a core component of the game in that you no longer need to avoid being voted out in order to win the game. It's no coincidence that Redemption Island has only ever been featured in seasons that include returning players, as it provides some of production's favorite players more than one opportunity to win the game. Considering this is the show's first experiment with Redemption Island, the results are not actually that disruptive to the game. Rather, one can't help but wonder how this season would have played out without the looming presence of Russell and Boston Rob, or if the two men had picked opposite buffs on Day 1. With that being said, even the new players in this cast aren't very entertaining or impressive. If you're a completionist or Survivor addict like me, watch it. Otherwise, I wouldn't blame you for spending season 22 on the sit-out bench.
39. Survivor: Thailand (5)
As someone who started watching Survivor in 2012, it is difficult to evaluate early seasons of the show. It's just a different beast. Jeff Probst was more reserved in his role, and the show focused much more on aspects of survival rather than strategy and storytelling. Thailand marks a sort of in-between in this way. Jeff begins narrating challenges and offering sass at tribal council more. And the most dominant winner the game had ever seen up until that point pushes Survivor more towards the strategic emphasis seen today. The problem here is that the winner's dominance is rather boring, albeit impressive, to watch play out. Casting standouts include Shii-Ann and Robb, but even their presence cannot save a rather boring cast. There are a few cringeworthy moments throughout the season that are also pretty hilarious, but it remains a bottom-tier season nonetheless.
38. Survivor: Palau (10)
You'll rarely see Palau ranked this low. The winner is one of the most beloved in the show's history, and the season's narrative is by far the most bizarre the show has ever seen. It involves one tribe absolutely decimating the other, which may be interesting to some, but I found it to be very boring. Emerging from the rubble of the Ulong tribe is another beloved castaway, but I never found them to be particularly engaging either. Season 10 does feature a unique WWII theme and one of the best finales, and certainly the best final immunity challenge out of the show's 40 seasons, but none of this is enough to save the rest of the season from bottom-tier status. To be clear, Palau is a big step up from Thailand and Redemption Island, and Ian Rosenberger might be one of my all-time favorite characters on the show. Unfortunately, there are much better iterations of Survivor out there.
37. Survivor: The Australian Outback (2)
This is another case where I'll admit I may just be too young to appreciate such an early season of the show. With that being said, season 2 is pretty damn boring. The cast is fantastic, evidenced by the fact that half of them have returned for a later season. There are also a few iconic moments in this season, including the show's first medical evacuation. The problem here is that a lot of the season's strategizing occurred off-camera, particularly during the walks to and from tribal council. Talking during these walks has since been prohibited, but it makes it difficult to track the narrative of the season, and especially difficult to understand the winner's path to victory, even if they are quite deserving. And while this season remains the most popular in the show's history, it's a little too quiet and slow compared to the several iterations that followed.
36. Survivor: One World (24)
I don't hate this season as much as others do, but it still fails in several areas. The winner is one of the most impressive the show has ever seen, but their victory is made incredibly obvious early on in the season. The gimmick this season is that both tribes must live on the same beach, which does lead to one very unique but very aggravating moment in which one tribe gives immunity to the other and voluntarily goes to tribal council. I've always felt this gimmick would have worked better if the tribes weren't split along gender lines. The tribal divisions instead lead to a disappointing boot order in which players with actual potential leave early and the merge is populated with easy pickings for our eventual winner. One World also features one of the least likable contestants of all time in Colton, whose ignorance and immaturity have an unfortunately high impact on the first half of the game. I did find Tarzan ("the game is afoot, Jeff") and Kat ("the, uh, appendix thing") to be good sources of comedic relief, but the gameplay this season is mostly incompetent and the narrative mostly fleeting. I wouldn't mind seeing the One World gimmick tried again, but season 24 was not a great introduction to the idea.
35. Survivor: Gamechangers (34)
Gamechangers saw the return of twenty "gamechanging" players, although not every player is quite the gamechanger the title suggests. It's a fine cast, but it is clear that the season was developed as an excuse to bring back certain production favorites. The result is an early exit for some true gamechangers, but also the emergence of some new greats, including the eventual winner. As a self-appointed Survivor scholar, I'd argue that Gamechangers is one of the most significant seasons in the show's history. If we were to divide the show into certain eras, season 34 marks the gateway into contemporary Survivor, dominated by idols, advantages, and twists. Today's Survivor is still a wholly compelling game - it may even be your favorite era of the show - but it is markedly different from what came before it. No moment highlights this idea better than the historic tribal council at final six where arguably the greatest player to never win is eliminated with no votes against them, as the result of too many idols/advantages existing in the game. Jeff celebrates the moment, but it can only be considered frustrating for fans of the game. This moment alone takes away from what is an otherwise exciting, albeit unevenly edited, season. An earlier moment in the season must also be mentioned as one of the most uncomfortable in the show's history, although I'd also argue, one of the most significant. Survivor has an uncanny ability to reveal certain aspects of human nature, both in its beauty and its ugliness. This particular scene illustrates a rather ugly act of desperation, and while likely triggering for many viewers, also reminds me why I find this show so special and so powerful. Gamechangers is a rather messy offering of Survivor, but it is a significant one nonetheless.
34. Survivor: Samoa (19)
Even if you have never watched Survivor, it is possible that you have heard the name Russell Hantz. He is, after all, one of the most notorious villains in reality television history. I mentioned him earlier in these rankings when he returned for the 22nd season, but it is here in Samoa that Russell makes his debut. Your enjoyment of this season, or lack thereof, will depend largely on how you feel about Russell. The edit focuses on him almost exclusively, which is a shame, because the season features a rather unique winner who only feels underwhelming due to their diminished presence in the season. Russell certainly makes for engaging television, although whether or not he is a great player is a more difficult question to answer. His gameplay makes for some interesting moments in Samoa, but his presence ultimately suppresses the season's several other character arcs. I personally find Survivor to be at its best when it crafts unique and balanced narratives for each of its characters, and "balanced" is not a word anyone would use to describe the show's 19th season.
33. Survivor: Borneo (1)
I may be performing Survivor sacrilege by listing the season that started it all so low in my rankings, but Borneo just doesn't hold up to the standard set by the many seasons that followed it. It is fascinating to watch the game play out for the very first time, and to witness the birth of concepts that are now commonplace such as forming an alliance. But the pacing is painfully slow, as the show operates much more like an Animal Planet documentary, observing its characters from a distance and even allowing Jeff to narrate camp life. I am grateful for Borneo and the seeds it planted for the show's future, but the show has evolved well beyond this initial offering, so I can only consider ranking this season so high. Still, it is recommended viewing for any fan of the show. Just don't start here or you may give up too rashly.
32. Survivor: Caramoan (26)
A very popular player wins this season in absolutely dominant fashion, but it was not necessarily difficult for them to pull it off. Whether or not you find that player to be entertaining or grating is a whole other question. Caramoan represents the show's second iteration of the "fans vs favorites" casting gimmick, in which ten returning players compete against ten first-timers. When Survivor first tried this out, they brought back a group of established legends and budding stars. Even the fans on Micronesia (which I will discuss later in these rankings) cemented themselves as a dynamic and capable group of players. Yet with a much larger pool of players to pick from, Caramoan manages to put together a pretty lackluster tribe of favorites. I mean, they brought back a freaking first boot! I've thought in the past that a season featuring a cast of all first boots would be interesting, but bringing back one in a season billed as bringing back a group of fan favorites is an, uh, interesting choice. Hilariously, they become the first player voted out on this season as well. The fans tribe is especially a disappointment here, as they are almost all entirely incompetent, with just one or two exceptions. The storytelling is not only uneven, but uncomfortably exploitative, taking advantage of genuine mental health issues. I also can't help but one wonder how this season would have played out had it not been for a certain medical evacuation. Still, there is a string of intense blindsides during the postmerge phase of the game that offer the exact drama we have come to expect from modern Survivor. When taken as a returnee season, Caramoan is a disappointment. But when taken as any other season of Survivor, Caramoan has a lot going for it.
31. Survivor: Marquesas (4)
Witness the birth of Survivor legend Boston Rob. His presence makes for a fantastic premerge, but the show really struggles when he is no longer around. Rob is the show's first character to outright embrace the game's invitation to manipulate and deceive, which makes him equal parts hilarious and chilling. Sean Rector is also one of the show's more underrated characters, and there is a strong narrative surrounding him and the eventual winner. Some brutal challenges and a Survivor first make Marquesas a highly memorable season, especially considering how early it is in the show's nearly 20-year run, but there are certainly stretches where the show seemingly doesn't have enough drama to make a story out of.
30. Survivor: Ghost Island (36)
The season that immediately followed HvHvH (which we'll talk about in a little bit), Ghost Island found a very clever way to incorporate advantages. The titular island refers to a separate island adorned with relics of the show's past. All the idols and advantages in this season came from popular moments in Survivor history. So while season 36 might spoil a lot of what comes before it, it works as a celebration of the moments that make this show so great. The season is dominated by a pair of great players, culminating in a historic finale. Of course, the pair's dominance does stifle the edit a bit. The boot order is fairly boring and predictable for that reason, but the cast is so damn likable that it somehow makes up for it. Some early boots seemed to have untapped potential, but I could imagine an eventual return for Donathan, Libby, Kellyn, or Dom as well. It's a fun, character-driven season. Just don't expect too many surprises.
29. Survivor: Edge of Extinction (38)
I could write an entire post about Edge of Extinction alone. It is by far the show's most experimental season, which leads to varying degrees of success. Season 38 puts a spin on the previously controversial Redemption Island twist by allowing players voted out of the game to live on another island and simply wait for their turn to compete to get back in the game. The experience was billed as putting players in some of the most desolate and difficult conditions the show had ever seen. However, the "Edge," as it came to be known, proved to be an easier place to live than the actual game, as more and more castaways joined to support one another and pal around as they shared information about the game. The result is a finale that is as exciting as it is unpredictable, but that also renders the entire postmerge mostly irrelevant. Visually, this season is one of Survivor's most impressive, especially in scenes focusing on the "Edge." Extreme closeups and extreme wide shots turn the "Edge" into an intimate and impactful setting, but I almost wish we could have seen more from the "Edge" so as to better understand the narratives that were developing there. The twist also robs us of Jeff's final thoughts at tribal council, which might be its most egregious sin! I could go on and on about the issues I have with this season's twist, but perhaps that is best left for another writeup. If you can look past the bizarre ending and ill-advised twist, this season has a lot to offer. It sees the return of four Survivor greats, one of which is arguably my all-time favorite player in David Wright. We also get introduced to several new and memorable characters, and there are several blindsides in the middle of this season that are an absolute blast to follow, even if they feel insignificant in hindsight.
28. Survivor: All-Stars (8)
The first returnee season of Survivor, All-Stars is a fascinating, if uneven, piece of television. Players entered the game with preexisting relationships, which can make the season's narrative difficult to follow, but also allows for some really interesting developments. Because of these prior friendships, emotions run high in All-Stars, which is both compelling and frustrating. Players take betrayals and backstabbings very personally, which can be understandable, but it can be awkward to watch players complain about their friendships rather than actually try to maneuver and play the game. Former winners and big threats are targeted early this season, which is sort of a shame, but it also allows for the emergence of new legends, players who may not have been "all-stars" coming into this season. Two of those players even become our very first Survivor married couple. Imagine having an entire season of a television show as a record of how you fell in love with your significant other. The romance is enjoyable to follow, but it does lower the stakes at the season's end. The experimental feel of season 8 makes it worth a watch as Survivor begins to reckon with what it means to turn people into television characters, especially across multiple iterations. The reunion show features Jeff and the cast discussing this idea at length, and I'd argue it is the best reunion in the show's history for this reason. The meta-conversations are complex and honest, with one castaway even leaving the reunion halfway through!
27. Survivor: Nicaragua (21)
I really love Nicaragua. I can't justify ranking it much higher than this, but I really, really love this season. It might be the unique and lovable winner, who remains one of my favorite characters of all time. Or it could be the fact that Jimmy freaking Johnson is on this season. Like, that's such a strange footnote in that man's life story. This season also jumpstarted the career of country singer Chase Rice (I don't listen to country, but that's still pretty cool), featured Jeff Probst at his absolute sassiest, and changed the way we think about the show's editing with the introduction of a "purple edit," which refers to a character seeming almost invisible in the show's edit, although I'd argue we had seen more egregious "purple edits" earlier in the show's history. It is almost like Nicaragua is a parody of Survivor, complete with a twist cornily named "The Medallion of Power," but so what if it is? I would totally watch an actual parody of the show, and it's even crazier that this is truly how the show's 21st season played out. It may not be Survivor at its best - in some ways, it may be Survivor at its worst - but it is thoroughly entertaining and remains a must-watch for any fan or reality television buff.
26. Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers (35)
I mentioned earlier how Gamechangers marked a shift towards a greater emphasis on twists and advantages in the game. The terribly named but thoroughly entertaining Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers follows in that tradition with a winner whose reliance on finding idols and taking advantage of twists highlighted a newly controversial path to victory. The winner owes a lot to a drastic change to the show's format, in which the final three is no longer decided by a vote at tribal council, but a firemaking challenge instead. I hate this change for several reasons, and I really wish it would go away, but I especially hate its debut here where players were never even warned about it. The tribal divisions here are corny and mostly meaningless, but I love any season with three tribes as opposed to two. The three-tribe setup just allows more room for the edit to breathe so that more characters can shine through. And if there is one thing this season has going for it, it is its characters. Lauren Rimmer is my personal favorite, but Devon, Ben, and Dr. Mike are all entertaining in their own way. Besides, the constant use of idols does make for some dramatic tribal councils, even if it isn't vintage Survivor.
25. Survivor: Worlds Apart (30)
Some ugly moments have complicated this season's legacy, but I find it very enjoyable. I'll never fault a season for ugly or controversial scenes. While they are unfortunate, and may not be a good look for those involved, they are still evidence of Survivor's uncanny ability to reveal certain aspects of human attitudes and behaviors. Still, Will and Dan do kinda suck. Anyway, we get another three-tribe setup here with a White Collar, Blue Collar, and No Collar tribe. I have no idea what "no collar" refers to, but the divisions work nonetheless. The winner plays an aggressive game, the type that usually doesn't win this game, but they pull it out via sheer physical domination towards the end. And for all the dark moments in this season, there are some hilarious ones as well.
24. Survivor: Island of the Idols (39)
One of the most recent seasons of Survivor is also likely the most controversial in the show's history. A diverse, dynamic, well-developed cast is overshadowed by the disgusting actions of one of its members. The show struggles to properly unfold the controversy surrounding Dan's inappropriate touching of women, even as it begins to impact gameplay as well. Obviously, the way this season unfolded is unfortunate, but it also held a much-needed mirror up to our own society. The way controversy and strategy began to blend into one felt eerily reminiscent of the kind of decision-making that continues to plague our systems and institutions. I therefore remained fascinated throughout Island of the Idols, even if that fascination was rooted in a sort of discomfort as well. But even beyond Dan's looming presence, I can't overlook all-time great characters like Noura, Jamal, Karishma, Janet, and Elaine. The season's twist is also a surprisingly enjoyable addition, even if it has very little impact on the outcome of the game. The eventual winner is rather bland, but the finale is exciting nevertheless. It's a very classic, character-driven season, despite modern Survivor's recent trend towards gameplay and strategy.
23. Survivor: Fiji (14)
Fiji is essentially now Survivor's permanent home. But much earlier in the show's run, it was just one stop in the show's journey around the globe. The season that shares its namesake remains memorable for a number of reasons. An early twist gets the season off to a rocky start. Tribes receive "have" and "have-not" status, which predictably leads to one tribe dominating the early stages of the game. Once the merge hits, however, Fiji is top-notch Survivor. We get one of the show's most well-orchestrated blindsides, and a slew of unique characters. Yau-Man and Dreamz remain two of my all-time favorites, and their "deal" is one of the show's more intriguing what-ifs. The winner is pretty obvious throughout, but their path remains compelling because they are so dynamic and likable. Fiji has seen countless Survivor players cross its beaches, but "The King of Fiji" can be found here. Don't miss this season.
22. Survivor: San Juan Del Sur (29)
Survivor introduced arguably its most drastic casting change in its 27th season by putting a tribe of returnees against a tribe of their loved ones. I remember hating the idea; isn't Survivor all about outwitting, outplaying, and outlasting a group of strangers? The result was a fresh and fascinating take on the basic Survivor concept. San Juan Del Sur improved upon Blood vs. Water's structure by eliminating Redemption Island and replacing it with hero duels that forced loved ones to compete against one another, with the added punishment of the loser going to Exile Island. This dynamic generates some great early drama, but it can't save an otherwise incredibly boring premerge. If you can power through the first half of this season, however, you are rewarded with one of the more cohesive narratives the show has ever produced. The winner plays an impressive game, one of the best I have ever seen, but I can't quite say I enjoy them as a character. The characters in San Juan Del Sur are all highly developed, yet I can't help but feel like they are all caricatures of themselves. There's the catty gay guy, the oft-divorced mother, and the immature misogynist. Too many characters on this season fall too neatly into the archetypes they were meant to represent, and the season suffers as a result. In the latter part of the season, Survivor editors do get the unique opportunity to create a relationship drama revolving around boyfriend Jon and girlfriend Jaclyn, resulting in some of the best storytelling techniques I've ever seen the show employ. They are really the only couple we have gotten to see play together since Rob and Amber in All-Stars, but we get an altogether different kind of romance here. Of course, there are still a couple standouts among the cast, namely Jeremy and Keith, but even their best work comes in a season I'll get to later on. If you're a fan of rom-coms or family dramas, San Juan Del Sur might be the Survivor season for you.
21. Survivor: Panama (12)
Panama is all about the characters. Terry, Cirie, Aras, Bruce, Shane, Courtney. I could go on. As far as I am concerned, up until season 12, no season in the show's history had developed characters this well before. Every member of the cast feels fresh and unique, and many of the aforementioned bunch represent archetypes we had never seen before. Cirie is likely the most memorable, but Terry gives us an incredible string of episodes towards the end of the season, and Shane provides a blend of humor and introspection that renders him one of the most complex characters of all time. The only problem is that a vast majority of these great characters find themselves on the same tribe, which can leave the season feeling a little unbalanced early on. Still, I consider Panama to be one of those transitional sort of seasons that I referred to earlier. The winner plays an "old school" game, if you will, arguably the final winning approach of this variety. The season is also referred to as Exile Island, named for the season's signature twist. It is the rare thematic twist to see itself repeated across several seasons. Exile Island becomes a key component of several seasons following its introduction here, and, as a result, it strongly contributes to some of the most personal and insightful character moments we have received.
20. Survivor: Cook Islands (13)
Cook Islands remains controversial for how it divided its tribes. Nicknamed Race Wars by fans, the season began with a white, black, Asian, and Hispanic tribe. I enjoy the theme, however. The four-tribe setup forced the show to feature a more diverse cast than ever, and also allowed the show to more directly engage with social issues. The cast also gives way to a few Survivor legends, as well as one very uninteresting character who has inexplicably returned several times. Looking at you, Candice. The winner is flat-out dominant, which can lead to some boring stretches. But many characters here are so funny, so dynamic, so well-developed, that the predictable nature of the season doesn't even matter. I also can't talk about this season without mentioning Cao Boi, a comedic relief character who proves to be much more, prompting a fascinating discussion on generational/cultural differences, and even introducing a Survivor strategy that continues to prevail today.
19. Survivor: Pearl Islands (7)
There's something about Pearl Islands that makes it feel so different from any other season. It might be the unique premiere, which provides players with the opportunity to gather supplies at a Panamanian market before being cast away. It could also be the season's pirate theme, which I found to be a bit hokey. Of course, Pearl Islands also features one of the worst twists in Survivor history. Before Edge of Extinction, before Redemption Island, there was the Outcasts twist, which allowed a "tribe" of voted-out players to vote two of their own back into the game. The twist has a huge impact on the season, which holds the season back a lot in my eyes. Still, Pearl Islands succeeds via its impressive cast. The winner is perhaps the most popular of all time, and their strategy remains unique even today. Rupert is clearly the star of this season, and he remains arguably the most popular player in Survivor history. Savage is a memorable early boot, and of course, Fairplay is not only an all-time great Survivor villain, but an all-time great TV villain. He gives us one of the most vile yet hilarious moments in the show's history. No loved ones visit has come close to topping that of Pearl Islands. We even get the first quit in Survivor history, which highlights an entirely new side of Jeff, and really the Survivor experience as a whole. I'm not as high on this season as most, but it's another one that I consider a must-watch for anyone trying to familiarize themselves with the show.
18. Survivor: South Pacific (23)
This season should not have worked. The follow-up to the putrid Redemption Island, South Pacific features an identical format, with two popular male returnees and the return of Redemption Island. One of the returnees is a challenge beast who I find to be one of the more overrated characters in the show's history, and the other is a bit of a meme coming into the season, but ends up playing a pretty impressive game. These aren't guys we really needed to see again, but they both end up contributing to the season in interesting and meaningful ways. I love the eventual winner of this season; they might just be the most underrated winner we have seen. This season also heavily focuses on religion as its core theme, which usually irritates me. Here, however, the use of faith as a manipulation device, and the conversations surrounding that strategy, leave South Pacific with one of Survivor's most cohesive and thought-provoking narratives. This season could easily go higher, but some boring characters keep it as a middle-tier offering.
17. Survivor: Guatemala (11)
Back when Survivor spent each season in a new location, that very location became a character of its own. Guatemala might just be my favorite place the show has ever visited, and it is precisely what makes this season so good. Castaways live amongst ancient Mayan ruins, and Mayan history is heavily incorporated into the game. Tribe names and challenge types are influenced by aspects of the culture, which proves both educational and engrossing. Any history buff or adventure seeker would find something they like about Survivor's 11th season. Of course, the cast is excellent as well. Judd is one of the most hilarious people to ever play the game, while Rafe, Danni, and Gary all receive satisfying narratives. This season also sees the return of one of the most popular players ever in Stephenie LaGrossa, and her story arc here is a surprising but intriguing addition to the one she received in Palau. Guatemala also introduces a twist that is now a Survivor mainstay: the hidden immunity idol. While the rules surrounding it have since changed, its inception here allows for some unique drama and some clever editing tricks.
16. Survivor: Winners at War (40)
Surely there's been some kind of mistake. Survivor's landmark 40th season must have been the greatest of all time, right? After all, it did pit 20 of the show's previous winners against one another in the ultimate battle for the Survivor crown, not to mention a particularly enticing two-million-dollar prize. This golden premise certainly renders Winners at War an exciting viewing experience, but a slew of twists and advantages hampers what could have been the perfect season of Survivor. Winners at War sees the return of the controversial Edge of Extinction twist, which is a bit more welcome here as it keeps some beloved characters on our screen longer, but its impact on the game remains troubling. And because the season is packed to the brim with great characters, twists, and advantages, the show really struggles to properly tell its story. Several episodes whiz by without us ever grasping how a certain vote played out or why a certain decision was made. Nevertheless, the winner of this season is incredibly shocking and satisfying. The finale episode is a whopping three hours (we miss out on what could have been an epic reunion as a result) which makes it one of the most thorough and engaging episodes in the show's history. While I wish a season of all winners had spent more time celebrating the show's past rather than ushering in its future, Survivor's most recent season is a superfan's dream come true, and still works as a proper send-off for several Survivor greats.
15. Survivor: Micronesia (16)
Survivor's first attempt at "Fans vs. Favorites" proved to be highly successful, acting as the perfect celebration of Survivor's standard-definition days, before Season 17 ushered in the era of HD. Micronesia is home to several of the show's most iconic moments, including what is commonly referred to as the worst move in Survivor history. Almost everyone came to play this season, and even the few that did not provide some incredible comedy early on in the season. Micronesia cemented several players as Survivor legends, and while I am not as high on the winner as others are, they are still entertaining to watch. A couple of medical evacuations, unfortunate in and of themselves, lead to an ill-advised twist at the end of the game, which is enough to hold this season back in my eyes. Still, this season is a smorgasbord of what makes Survivor so special.
14. Survivor: Africa (3)
Survivor's third season remains one of the most harsh, punishing seasons we have ever seen. Kenyan wildlife present a legitimate threat to the castaways, and water is especially hard to come by. The conditions do seem to sap certain contestants of the energy needed to play the game, but the standouts in the cast more than make up for it. Just about everyone plays a role in this season's narrative. Early boots like Silas and Clarence are multifaceted characters with complete narrative arcs. This season also marks a huge step forward in regards to Survivor strategy, and a large part of that is due to its players. Lex and T-Bird remain two of the best strategists and social mavericks the game has seen, while the winner introduces a new archetype that would only grow in significance over time. Africa is also one of the show's funniest seasons, largely thanks to Big Tom, but there is also Frank, who is unintentionally hilarious. Africa shows its age at times, with moments that likely would not fly in 2020, but honestly, these moments only add to the season's hilarity, and work as a fascinating time capsule from 2001.
13. Survivor: The Amazon (6)
Like Africa, The Amazon shows its age, with certain gendered comments feeling out of place when you watch the show today. These comments are fueled by the season's tribal lines, with an all-boys and an all-girls tribe to start the game. The season tends to sexualize its women and emphasize potential relationships between both sexes, which is equal parts hilarious and uncomfortable. The castaways do lean into this dynamic, of course. Two girls even strip naked during a challenge because they want chocolate and peanut butter, and those same two end up posing in Playboy after the season's end. As a senior at the University of Pittsburgh, I love the fact that a Pitt junior wins this season, even if I'm not too impressed with their game. Most viewers of this season, myself included, will feel like a certain other player should have reached the end and won, as their gameplay is some of the most impressive the show had seen, ushering in an entirely new era of Survivor.
12. Survivor: Blood vs. Water (27)
I referenced this season earlier as the original incarnation of the Blood vs. Water concept. The casting here is very good, bringing back a group of players whose returns were welcome, and in some cases, surprising. Colton is the one returnee I could have done without, but his boyfriend Caleb is an enjoyable addition to the season. Tyson, Aras, Monica, and Gervase all see their Survivor stories developed in interesting ways. Aras' brother Vytas is also a unique and dynamic character, and the pair are particularly fascinating in relation to one another. Newcomers Hayden and Ciera also remain two of my all-time favorites. Hayden, the former Big Brother 12 winner, seems like the exact kind of guy who could win a season if given a second chance. The format of this season allows for unique narratives and themes to play out that emphasize relationships. I recall this season encouraging complex conversations with my parents about family, loyalty, and love. There is a dominant alliance in this season that faces little competition, but the story is told so well that it doesn't even matter. Redemption Island is unfortunately a component of the season, although it feels surprisingly welcome this time around. Blood vs. Water was a huge risk for the show at the time, but it remains one of the most daring seasons of television I have ever seen.
11. Survivor: China (15)
China is another season that excels due in large part to its location. Chinese culture is beautifully integrated into the season, with a Buddhist ceremony even marking the start of the competition. China truly is unlike anywhere Survivor has ever traveled, and this season benefits greatly from that fact. A few Survivor legends emerge out of this season as well, including Amanda, Todd, Courtney, and James. Courtney especially stands out as one of the most brutally honest castaways of all time, offering some of the best confessionals the show has seen. There are a few castaways that seem like obvious fodder, which holds back the season just the slightest bit for me. The theme of China is sloppy strategy, but the winner gives an incredible performance at the Final Tribal Council that singlehandedly secures them the win. There are several iconic moments here, and it is another must-watch for any fan of the show.
10. Survivor: Tocantins (18)
As we move into the top ten, it will become abundantly clear what I value in a season of Survivor, which I think speaks more broadly to what I value in my storytelling. Tocantins may only be the season to kick off the top ten, but it does act as a clear indicator of my storytelling interests. Well-developed characters are again essential to this season's success, with Tyson, Coach, Stephen, Taj, and J.T. the obvious standouts. Tyson provides a snarky sense of humor that reminds both players and viewers not to take things too seriously, but it is Coach who emerges as the absolute greatest source of comedy the show has ever produced. Seriously, this guy might be the overall greatest character the show has ever produced, especially in his debut here. Taj, on the other hand, renders the season especially heartfelt and sincere. The winner also succeeds via sheer likability, playing the first "perfect game" in Survivor history by getting zero votes cast against them all season, and winning unanimously at the very end. The interactions between all of these characters are such a joy to watch as strategy is only lightly applied over a season that is primarily about human relationships. Of course, strategy remains a significant and a welcome component of the game, but it is the social aspect of Survivor that makes it so innovative, and very few seasons highlight that the way Tocantins does.
9. Survivor: Kaoh Rong (32)
Kaoh Rong is remembered as easily the most brutal season of Survivor, which leads to one of my all-time favorite episodes of the show. Early in the season, a reward challenge under the beating sun of Cambodia results in three separate players passing out due to heat exhaustion, and one of them being pulled from the game. The outcome is disappointing, and the entire scene is uncomfortable in the most impressive way possible. The episode peels the curtain back on the show's production, as cast and crew struggle to deal with a situation they clearly have never faced before. Kaoh Rong acts as a unique reminder that Survivor is a highly manufactured and yet a very real environment. There is nothing else quite like it in its ability to push real people to their brink, while converting that push into entertainment. In many ways, it's a cruel experiment. But it also challenges viewers to reckon with how they view and how they value the characters in their own lives. Other disturbing moments stand out as some of Kaoh Rong's most memorable, including an infection forcing another player out of the game, and a bug crawling into a player's ear. But if these examples sound too disgusting or unsettling, there is still plenty more that Kaoh Rong has going for it. A three-tribe setup starts the game, with a "brain", "brawn", and "beauty" tribe. The divisions sound corny, as they did when Survivor first tried this out in its 28th season. But both seasons excelled under such a theme, likely because the labels do map on quite nicely to the show's "outwit, outplay, outlast" mantra. The assignments feel a little more arbitrary in this second iteration of the theme, but complex characters still emerge. Tai is an all-time great casting find, and Jason is an intriguingly sympathetic villain in the season's narrative, something the show never really tried before. Aubry and Cydney emerge as two of modern Survivor's better strategists, and Debbie's overall absurdity is hilarious on its own, but even better in conjunction with the clever editing innovations she inspires.
8. Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains (20)
Twenty seasons is a huge milestone for any television show, so it only made sense that Survivor marked the occasion with arguably its biggest season yet. The show had already taken a stab at an All-Stars season, which met mixed reactions. So, to commemorate a decade of Survivor, the show brought back some of its most beloved and most hated characters for its most competitive season yet. The casting here is excellent, appropriately representing 12 of the show's first 19 seasons. It is littered with previous winners as well as a few players who came up just short. And because the cast is so stacked, the stakes feel so incredibly high at every given moment. Every elimination feels meaningful because the player leaving is a household name. Besides, it is worth noting Heroes vs. Villains was only the fourth time Survivor brought back returning players, and only the second season to include strictly returnees. Just about every player sees their legacy expanded upon in new and interesting ways. Jerri, Sandra, and J.T. are especially notable for showing us entirely new aspects of themselves, both as people and as players. Russell and Parvati also improve upon their previous appearances, making some of the most impressive and unpredictable moves in Survivor history. Heroes vs. Villains is best watched after all the seasons that precede it, but its sheer intensity makes it enjoyable for any and all viewers.
7. Survivor: Cagayan (28)
Cagayan marks Survivor's first experiment with the "brain vs. brawn. vs beauty" dynamic that Kaoh Rong would later employ. It is no wonder that producers chose to bring the concept back for round two, as its debut here is nothing short of fantastic. Players lean rather heavily into the theme in this first iteration, with the beauty tribe in particular providing us with comedy gold by talking about how attractive and totally not vain they are. The brain tribe is one of the most beautiful shitshows in television history, offering up some great characters in the premerge and some significant late-gamers as well. The Spencer-Tasha duo is a joy to watch, and I much prefer Chaos Kass to the subdued version we get of her in Cambodia. Trish is a hilarious and refreshing take on the "mom" archetype, speaking her mind and welcoming confrontation much more than middle-aged women tend to do on the show. The winner plays an aggressive game, perhaps the most aggressive of all time. It's honestly a miracle that they won, but it's impressive nonetheless. Alongside Tocantins and a few others I will get to in a bit, Cagayan is one of the first seasons I'd recommend to a newcomer. It feels like a nod to some Survivor classics, while still working within the framework of modern Survivor's reliance upon big moves and idol plays.
6. Survivor: Philippines (25)
Philippines will always have a special place in my heart as the season that started it all. The show's 25th season was my very first, and remains one of my favorites today. Like Cagayan, There's something about Philippines that just feels so classic. After a string of seasons that were not very well received, it seems Survivor looked to return to its roots with a mostly gimmick-free season. I applaud this season for being the rare season to feature a mix of newbies and returnees and offer no clear advantage to the returning players. Such seasons are often created simply to coronate a production favorite, but Philippines simply introduces returnees as an element in the game, not the element. The returnees this season are far from the stars of the show, although I will always appreciate more Jonathan Penner on my television screen, and Russell Swan does receive one of the more tragic two-season story arcs in the show's history. Swan's Matsing tribe is one of the most glorious messes I have ever seen on TV, and every one of its members receives a satisfying narrative arc, even first boot Zane and Angie "cookies" Layton. There are also the wonderful villains of the Tandang tribe, Pete, Abi-Maria, and RC. This season features one of my favorite winners, and has become my go-to season for getting newcomers hooked.
5. Survivor: Gabon (17)
Gabon is SO. MUCH. FUN. It's a shitshow, sure, throwing just about everything we thought we knew about Survivor out the window, but it's a fun shitshow nonetheless. Nothing goes according to plan this season, resulting in one of the most unpredictable and chaotic seasons Survivor has ever seen. The winner is not very impressive, but this season, more than any other, is about the journey, not the destination. A lot of people say we get a weak final three in Gabon because all the weak players eliminate the strong ones early on, but I disagree. I'm not even sure Gabon has any strong players, just crazy ones. It truly is the trashy reality TV season of Survivor, complete with over-the-top villains and overly dramatic tears. Most of the tears this season come from a single castaway, but there are lots and lots of tears nonetheless. And yet, despite the absurd nature of so many of these characters, many of them emerge as some of the most relatable players we have seen. Randy, Sugar, and GC are all just so out-there that they actually feel pretty normal. If you are looking for complex strategy and wholesome relationships, Gabon may disappoint you. But if you want wild characters and even wilder moments, Gabon may be your Survivor guilty pleasure.
4. Survivor: David vs. Goliath (37)
Many of Survivor's most recent seasons are ranked pretty damn low on my list. But not all is lost for the future of Survivor. One of the show's most recent seasons is one of the absolute best products the show has ever put out. David vs. Goliath features a pretty corny theme, but the theme gives way to two highly compelling tribes and an incredibly balanced edit. The editors employ some new techniques here that keep the show feeling fresh after 37 seasons, and allow each and every character to shine. Christian is my personal favorite in the cast, a hilarious and insightful player who feels like a proper reinvention of the classic "nerdy guy" archetype. Davie, Nick, John, and Mike are also all welcome additions to the bunch, feeling familiar and fresh all at once. Even the villains on this season are a blast; Angelina is unknowingly hilarious, and Natalie will go down as one of the most memorable premergers we have ever seen. An influx of idols and advantages should have hurt David vs. Goliath the way it did many prior seasons, but they are handled much more responsibly this time around, by both players and producers. Contemporary Survivor feels drastically different from the nearly two decades that precede it, but David vs. Goliath reminds us that change isn't always a bad thing.
3. Survivor: Vanuatu (9)
A good winner doesn't always make for a good season, but in the case of Vanuatu, the winner's journey is precisely what propels this season into my top three. Like The Amazon before it, Vanuatu splits its men and women into two separate tribes. The dynamic this time around feels less like a wannabe dating show, and more like a true battle of the sexes. Tribal lines seem impenetrable, which makes it all the more impressive as the eventual winner beats the odds and maneuvers their way to the end. The foundation for their eventual win is established in the very first episode; I truly believe Vanuatu to be a masterclass in storytelling. As with any other great season, there are several memorable characters, including Scout, Eliza, Twila, and Sarge. The confessionals on this season feel especially noteworthy. Contrast Chris' emotionally charged way of speaking to us with Ami's ice-cold delivery. Both characters are among my all-time favorites, and showcase the range of personalities and experiences that Survivor welcomes.
2. Survivor: Millenials vs. Gen-X (33)
If you didn't think some of the aforementioned themes were corny, surely you'll find the pitting of generations against one another to be unbearably so. Still, the theme renders this season one of the most heartfelt seasons of television I have ever watched. That's not to say there are no stakes, because there are, but rather that the characters and their relationships with one another are so incredibly moving. The season is also a testament to Survivor's longevity; in the show's first few seasons, Gen-Xers were the young people. Here, in the show's 33rd season, Generation X is the older of the two tribes. And while I hate to make generalizations about entire groups of people, especially with labels as arbitrary as generations, this season does generate some interesting discussions. Hannah's struggle with anxiety is a significant moment to include on television, and highlights an experience that all generations can relate to, but that has particularly impacted young people. The fact that she emerges as one of the season's best strategists is a testament to her character and to the power of the Survivor experience. David Wright makes his debut here, also emerging as a fantastic strategist in addition to a dynamic narrator. His character bridges a gap of sorts between the Millenial and the Gen-X tribe, and it can be comforting to see an older character on the show who still struggles mentally from time to time. But it is another Gen-Xer who gives us what is, in my humble opinion, the absolute greatest character moment in the history of the show. Bret LaBelle, a police sergeant from Boston, comes out to Zeke Smith in one of the most touching and important scenes I have ever seen in a television show. It captures the theme perfectly, but also transcends Survivor as a whole. It's beautiful, thought-provoking, and humorous all at once. Millenials vs. Gen-X is a lighthearted season by most accounts, but its likable and close-knit cast makes it a unique and rewarding viewing experience.
Now, without further ado...The greatest Survivor season of all time is...
1. Survivor: Cambodia (31)
Damn, Cambodia is good. It simply had to be. Also referred to as Survivor: Second Chance, it featured a cast of twenty players who lost in their first go-around, and were chosen via a fan vote for a second opportunity to win this game. The fan vote heightened viewers' investment in the season, and raised the stakes every step of the way. Seriously, every second of this season just feels BIG. The edit crafts some really compelling narratives around each player, explaining what they are trying to do differently in their second chance, and why this opportunity is so important to them. Of course, Cambodia spoils a lot of what comes before it for this reason, but once you work your way up to this season, the payoff is more than worth it. It can also be a daunting season for newcomers as it is very strategy-heavy. There are plenty of great character moments, but this season does a lot to advance Survivor strategy and develop meta-conversations surrounding it. Hearing players talk about how different archetypes and dynamics figure into their strategy is this Survivor fan's wet dream, but it may not be for everyone. The winner plays a flawless game, technically a perfect one if you'll forgive the negated votes against them, and the buildup to their win is both satisfying and heartwarming. It's also just thrilling to see players spanning nearly two decades of Survivor come together, reworking old approaches, adopting new ones, and quite literally changing the game forever.
Wow, that was a lot of words. I hope these rankings inspired you to try at least one season of this incredible show, or go back and watch some old ones if you are already a fan! I will continue to provide Survivor-related content throughout the year, taking a deeper dive into one of television's most layered and profound programs over the last twenty years.